Michigan Sportsman Forum banner
  • From treestands to ground blinds, all your hunting must-haves can be found at Bass Pro Shops. Shop Now.

    Advertisement
21 - 40 of 135 Posts
For the people that don't reload there's Black Butterfly Ammo...
.450 BUSHMASTER, 160 gr, FLAT BASE RAPTOR “SCREAMER” 2775 FPS
https://www.blackbutterflyammunition.com/pages/450-bushmaster-160-gr-flat-base-raptor-screamer
They have lots of different bullet choices at around double the cost. They even have the 300 XTP MAG at a reasonable price. All of it still less expensive per round than premium saboted slugs, and far better ballistics, terminal performance, and consistent accuracy.

https://www.blackbutterflyammunition.com/catalog/ammo/rifle?q=450+Bushmaster&sort=
 
Discussion starter · #24 ·
2775 fps Really.Do we need to blow the deer in half or what?
Lol, well its shooting a balsa wood bullet at those speeds. Not close to 250 grams, very light with maybe a low BC.
Might be worse than the 250 on real game.

Maybe they are attempting to get 30-06 performance for people shooting in the shotgun zone. Did they list the BC of those light bullets?
 
Lol, well its shooting a balsa wood bullet at those speeds. Not close to 250 grams, very light with maybe a low BC.
Might be worse than the 250 on real game.

Maybe they are attempting to get 30-06 performance for people shooting in the shotgun zone. Did they list the BC of those light bullets?

They won't admit the BC. Has said "pending" for over a year. They list the length as .868". The Barnes 200 grain copper hollow point is .811", with .160 BC.

The bullet in that ammo is a Cutting Edge Raptor, which is available separately as a component, from Cutting Edge. The bullet is designed for 1-2" of penetration (as said on both sites). After that, in their wording "The top portion of the bullet blows off into six petals and moves away from the main wound channel". So, you take a bullet with a miserable BC to start with, have it penetrate 1", totally destabilize and lose an unknow amount of weight, then expect the base to straight line penetrate to the vitals???????????? Those petals alone are not going to have enough mass to penetrate anything significant.

As far as the velocity number, that's what they are selling. Like you said, they could make an aluminum bullet with a wood core, and boost velocity numbers. Essentially what they did is make a very short bullet with a huge hollow point and the whole front half of the bullet is nylon.

By the way, if velocity is the goal- In a bolt action or single shot, 2900 FPS is easily attainable with the 200 grain Barnes copper bullet that wasn't built to self destruct.
 
Discussion starter · #26 ·
They have lots of different bullet choices at around double the cost. They even have the 300 XTP MAG at a reasonable price. All of it still less expensive per round than premium saboted slugs, and far better ballistics, terminal performance, and consistent accuracy.

https://www.blackbutterflyammunition.com/catalog/ammo/rifle?q=450+Bushmaster&sort=
I'm not so sure on this one for deer. "these hollow points are designed to "bloom" and open three razor sharp petals which "chop" their way through the target as the projectile rotates. This helps to dump a massive amount of energy on impact and reduce over penetration or "pass through" especially on light big game animals like deer when hit in the rib cage area.

These would seem to ruin more meat. If you want to do a double lung shot you need the full pass though so you collapse the lungs faster. This bullet wants to blow them up from the inside like a varmint round.
I have no doubt it will dump energy but might tear up the meat in the process. With a .45 call you want over penetration if going for the double lung. Goal is to collapse both lungs.
 
I'm not so sure on this one for deer. "these hollow points are designed to "bloom" and open three razor sharp petals which "chop" their way through the target as the projectile rotates. This helps to dump a massive amount of energy on impact and reduce over penetration or "pass through" especially on light big game animals like deer when hit in the rib cage area.

These would seem to ruin more meat. If you want to do a double lung shot you need the full pass though so you collapse the lungs faster. This bullet wants to blow them up from the inside like a varmint round.
I have no doubt it will dump energy but might tear up the meat in the process. With a .45 call you want over penetration if going for the double lung. Goal is to collapse both lungs.

If you're talking about this one? It's subsonic for the 1:16 twist rifles.

https://www.blackbutterflyammunitio...zsaw-1x20-d-12-bba-450-425-buzzsaw-1x20-d-12-bba-450-425-buzzsaw-1x20-d-12-2112
 
How is being subsonic aside from being less noisy of benefit?
Subsonic is no benefit to me, I was just pointing that out.

I'm perfectly happy with the Hornady Black 250 FTX, it has never let me down.

I would like to see them load the 250 Monoflex as another option.
 
Discussion starter · #30 ·
Subsonic is no benefit to me, I was just pointing that out.

I'm perfectly happy with the Hornady Black 250 FTX, it has never let me down.

I would like to see them load the 250 Monoflex as another option.
Agree the 250 is great price and accuracy. An option for a different type of bullet would be icing on the cake.
 
Discussion starter · #31 ·
I see there are a few more commercial 450 BM ammo options now. Since midway carries can we assume that these loads are more trustworthy than ammo from the smaller unheard of companies that might overload or under load the rounds due to poor quality control?

Anyone try some of the ones listed?
Image
 
I've been looking at the Black Butterfly site and have interest in a completely different route. I'm using it as an excuse to buy a new rifle to hang off a tree with. The shot opportunities in my area are a short range affair of mostly 30 yards and under. I don't need speed and don't want to make a deer look like a jackrabbit shot with a 30-06. I'd like to slow things down a lot and go with a heavy subsonic. Black Butterfly makes a 425 grainer that would fit the bill.

Would a 1:16 twist in the Ruger American stabilize a bullet (1.382 inches) that long? It might be worth a tax stamp and associated costs.

I throw heavies out of my .45 colt Blackhawk but I already own that. :)
 
Discussion starter · #33 · (Edited)
I've been looking at the Black Butterfly site and have interest in a completely different route. I'm using it as an excuse to buy a new rifle to hang off a tree with. The shot opportunities in my area are a short range affair of mostly 30 yards and under. I don't need speed and don't want to make a deer look like a jackrabbit shot with a 30-06. I'd like to slow things down a lot and go with a heavy subsonic. Black Butterfly makes a 425 grainer that would fit the bill.

Would a 1:16 twist in the Ruger American stabilize a bullet (1.382 inches) that long? It might be worth a tax stamp and associated costs.

I throw heavies out of my .45 colt Blackhawk but I already own that. :)
A 1/24 twist will stabilize a 320 grain bullet. I ran the numbers using 1100 and 1200 fps on 4 calculators all 4 said comfortably stable. So you should be ok there.

The 250gr hornady does not seem to tear them apart. you will get a full passthrough at 30-160 yards. The exit hole on mine was small not much bigger than the entrance hole.

I'm not sure what advantage a 1/2 velocity heavier bullet will have. It should have more initial shock value, I'm sure someone will chime in the answer.

Found another company selling subsonic for the 450BM.
https://detroitammoco.com/product/subsonic-450-bushmaster-300gr-xtpmag/
 
Discussion starter · #35 ·
Well I would think the 285gr bullet would be woods and swamp load, that's where I would use it !!!
So if you were 30 yards from the deer the slower 285gr would be better than a faster 250gr because it does more shock damage?

I think the heavier bullet would be harder to deflect from tree branches.

I guess it depends on how you want to kill them. I'm thinking a double lung pass though will collapse both lungs = dead deer. This might be more likely with a faster bullet at close range.

Is the 285gr more forgiving on miss placed shots?
Would it not do more tissue damage and ruin more meat?

I don't really know one way or another so welcome someone to explain further.
 
Discussion starter · #37 ·
I've been looking at the Black Butterfly site and have interest in a completely different route. I'm using it as an excuse to buy a new rifle to hang off a tree with. The shot opportunities in my area are a short range affair of mostly 30 yards and under. I don't need speed and don't want to make a deer look like a jackrabbit shot with a 30-06. I'd like to slow things down a lot and go with a heavy subsonic. Black Butterfly makes a 425 grainer that would fit the bill.

Would a 1:16 twist in the Ruger American stabilize a bullet (1.382 inches) that long? It might be worth a tax stamp and associated costs.

I throw heavies out of my .45 colt Blackhawk but I already own that. :)
Makers Bullets produces the 425 gr. bullet for Black Butterfly.....its a sub-sonic load depending on temperature, humidity and elevation a little over 1000 fps....
I've talked to Paul owner of Makers Bullets several times....he uses a Ruger American with 1-16" twist to test the 425 gr. bullets it works great....
I have 200 of the 425 gr. to load....when the weather breaks will be testing them....
 
21 - 40 of 135 Posts