Michigan Sportsman Forum banner
  • From treestands to ground blinds, all your hunting must-haves can be found at Bass Pro Shops. Shop Now.

    Advertisement

Lets do some meat math.

12K views 178 replies 56 participants last post by  Ranger Ray  
#1 ·
I want to compare venison to beef.

I shot 3 does this season that yielded a total of roughly 130 lbs of cleaned meat.

Now please help me break this meat down into cuts.

Total: 130 lbs.
Ground: 65 lbs.
Chops/back straps: 24 lbs.
Steaks: 15 lbs.
Roasts: 15 lbs.
Tenderloins: 3 lbs
Cut stew meat: 8 lbs.
Does this sound about right to you?

If that seems accurate, help me calculate what these cuts would cost as beef.

MY YIELD IN BEEF PRICES:
Ground: 65 lbs. Ă— 3.50/lb. =$227.50.
Chops/back straps: 24 lbs. Ă— 9.00/lb. = $216.00.
Steaks: 15 lbs. Ă— 4.00/lb. = $60.00.
Roasts: 15 lbs. Ă— 6.00/lb. =$90.00.
Tenderloins: 3 lbs Ă— 25.00/lb =$75.00.
Cut stew meat: 8 lbs. Ă— 7.00/lb = $56.00
Total: $724.50.
That seems outrageous considering venison, when bought at the store, is more costly than beef.
I could be off on my yielded weight per cut as well as the current beef pricing per cut. What do you come up with?
 
#4 ·
Depends how you figure the price per pound. Typically when you buy a 1/4 or 1/2 beef, it’s all the same price per pound, so the good cuts cost the same as burger.

Venison is still pretty cheap if you cut your own, considering tag price. We eat mostly venison all year, but I do have my name on a 1/4 beef come April. We will supplement our venison with that. Pork is still pretty cheap too, if you buy direct from a farmer. I raise my own chickens, too. Probably not as cheap as the store, but I do know what they were fed.
 
#10 ·
When you buy a beef a quarter or half at a time, your paying hang weight. So, $3.50 per lb hang weight. That’s hide, fat, meat and bone. If you weight your take home, it’s more like 6 to 8 dollars a lb. Definitely worth it for prime cuts and about even or slightly high for burger. Compared to venison, there is no comparison. I process my own. $20 a tag and time. Buy all my packaging in bulk so cost is minimal. I figure every deer saves me approximately $200 off my grocery bill.
 
#25 ·
Haven't paid all that much attention at the grocery store, probably make me 🤮. Know don't get much for amount of $$$$.
But would say ground JUNK is much more then 3.50# no comparison to prime deer ground!
Back straps I would compare to any prime cut of beef (for me anyways) so say a ribeye for someone who would choose beef over venison.
9$/# is also MUCH cheaper than what a ribeye will go for (think)...

Leg steaks, which I get a lot of from deer (hind quarters) and some front quarters are again much more enjoyable then most all beef steaks. Maybe a Ribeye might beat em, sometimes.
Would most definitely say again, WAY more expensive then 4$/#.
Don't do roast or stew so can't speak for them.

I'm crossing fingers I'll kill another tomorrow. I've got room and bubb and I are going to eat 3 this year no doubt about it. Muscle food and she loves it as much as myself. When ma left she started eating the burger.. Unaware too her... "dad these tacos, nachos are SO good"... "Dad these burgers are the best"... Ma wasn't a fan of the burger.... Bubbs IS so that's that much more burger we're flying through.
 
#27 ·
Yield from a field dressed deer is typically around 50% of dressed weight. So 120lb doe you can expect around 60lbs of meat assuming little or no meat loss from damage, spoilage, etc. if you are very diligent about using every scrap of meat off the bone.

I figure after yesterdays doe i will have put about 150lbs of venison in the freezer this year. After I did my fuzzy math it would take approx. 4 deer and me butchering them all myself for me to get a freezer full cheaper than buying a quarter cow (not prepackaged beef).

If you are comparing to prepackaged beef at the local grocery store, and assuming you are rolling no incidental costs into the price of venison other than tags (ie: ammo, gas, new camo, new gun, broadhead, food plot seed, etc.) then the price per lb of venison is much more attractive than the $3.50+ per lb of retail beef. Of course many of us (including myself) spend hundreds and sometimes thousands in a calendar year on hunting pursuits so by the time you factor in all your incidentals into the cost per pound in all but the most conservative estimates you probably would have saved money buying a quarter cow instead.

But where’s the fun in that? We hunt and spend money hunting because it’s our passion. I try not to compare bills to the grocery store too much.
 
#31 ·
I'm talking meat only not everything else involved lol.
However personally I know I'm on top. I've had 2 bows my whole life, fuel isn't a factor as I can walk to or drive 8 minutes to my hunting property. I can butcher myself so tags really are all I have into it other than when I gun hunt which I've had the same box of ammo for 3 years now. Only takes one to make sure the scope is on and one to kill the deer.
 
#28 ·
The Beef prices quoted to me this year for a whole cow was 3.30 per lb + 1.00 per pound processing. Thats live weight. I passed this year and headed to the woods and shot 2 bucks and 2 does.

Figured when i want beef, i can pickup some beef cheaper than 4.30 per lb. Rest of year, offset with venison (which we prefer anyway being leaner)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Papa Liver
#34 ·
Backstraps are way under priced That’s filet mignon right there so at least 20 bucks a pound.
 
#36 ·
The whole subject is very complex. I can make a case that you can go buy a $ 100 12ga single shot and a box of 5 buckshot, wear whatever clothes you have around the house, hunt public land on 11/15 and fill a couple tags, process it yourself and it's pretty reasonable meat. Or, like most of us it's probably $20 lb if you count time off work etc
 
#39 ·
I got 62 package of meat from my buck processed packs one pound charges 120 so I figure cheap meat since I just hunt by my house only have to bug license will never have to buy anything for hunting not evan shells got ten for deers and ten for turkeys ii don’t think I will be able to hunt many more so 60 packs at least 120 to 150 meals for total cost with licens 140 dollersless than dollar meal
 
#40 ·
Several years ago a young neighbor lady took me up on my offer to teach her how to butcher a deer.

She had a small doe that had been roadkilled with a broken neck.

We got it hung and skinned - then I started showing her how to take the backstraps, then taking front shoulders off - and let her go to work.

I swear this girl did a job army ants would be proud of.

Guestimate - a 110 lbs doe yeilded a good 40 lbs (two 3 1/2 gallon buckets) of cleaned meat - and nearly that in "other".

Tenacious kid...