close

Privacy guaranteed - Your email is not shared with anyone.

IDing Menominee vs Whitefish

Discussion in 'Big Lake Surf/ Pier Reports' started by fishoak, Oct 25, 2010.

  1. fishoak

    fishoak
    Expand Collapse

    133
    16
    Trophy Points:
    873
    Location:
    Grand Haven
    Starting this as separate thread as is a different topic...

    I know generally, Whitefish get bigger and I believe are slightly broader than a Menominee...but is there a sure identifier to use to tell the difference between two of about the same size?

    In looking at the MI DNR Fish ID pages, it looks like the Whitefish has a slight hump on the back above the gill plates?

    In the recent post by FishSlayer with the pic with 6 fish showing (4 Menom/2 White) 5 of the 6 seem to look about the same in body shape? And the hump I was looking for doesn't seem obvious in the pic except for the big one? So, I'm not sure which is which...
     
  2. Fishslayer5789

    Fishslayer5789
    Expand Collapse

    3,047
    9
    Trophy Points:
    2,073
    Location:
    Traverse City, MI
    Menominee have a light brown tint to their backs and have a more slender/torpedo-shaped body than a whitefish. In that picture I posted the middle fish in each group of 3 is a whitefish and the 2 fish on the outside of each group are menominee.
     

  3. limige

    limige
    Expand Collapse

    8,765
    198
    Trophy Points:
    2,533
    Location:
    nw lp, mi
    is menominee the same as cisco? if so the mouths are different, whitefish have a bottom feeder mouth whereas cisco have a normal fish mouth.
     
  4. sfw1960

    sfw1960
    Expand Collapse
    Staff Member Super Mod Mods
    1. Ice fishing Around Grand Rapids/Greenville
    2. Saginaw River Icefishing

    14,590
    204
    Trophy Points:
    2,533
    Location:
    Newaygo County...(49349)
    A cisco is a lake herring, nope diff critter - but dang tasty also.