What lake produces best L.P. Eye's?

[Nine Milly]

I know this is very debateable, but in your opinion, what lake in the L.P. of Michigan consistantly produces the steadiest catch of Walleye through the ice? Im fed up with chasing Psedo-populations of them here in the s.w. corner.

[Ladykiller]

Steadiest? as in the most consistent numbers of fish per day?

size is not a factor? taste is not a factor? I'd have to say Lake Huron my friend, Saginaw Bay to be precise.

[Nine Milly]

Sorry, I guess I should have made the question about "edible" and "steady" numbers of eyes lol. sorry

[ih772]

Still Lake Huron...lol. :D

Do you mean inland lake?

[east bay ed]

hubbard lake gives up a pretty steady stream of walleyes during the winter. i would also look at lake charlivoix(sp) on the west side. i know hubbard gives up very clean fish that are excellent in a pan.
on the west side i would look at muskegon lake as well. i don't know how clean the fish are but they do have some good numbers.

[Mitch]

Hodenpyle Pond.

[sfw1960]

I wonder how the ice is on Hodenpyl....
lotsa eYes in there....Tippy also....:eek:

[JJ Mac]

My favorites are:

Inland Lakes:

Quantity: Size:
Burt Lake Lake Charlevoix
Black Lake Portage Lake (UP)
Hubbard Lake



Great Lakes:

West end Lake Erie Basin
Munuscong Bay
Saginaw Bay
Little Bay DeNoc

[Ralph Smith]

Hubbard is definately the best I've found. And Ed is right, 4 of us stayed there for a weekend last winter, and ate every fish we caught, was going take a few home, but they were to good. Even after the Venison burgers we were grilling out by the shanty that got Eds taste buds going. Remember those babies Ed? :D

[ih772]

If you know where to go, Houghton Lake can be a good place too.

[east bay ed]

yes i do remember it. i remember being very hungry and going home hungry. just kidding. they did smell good though.