Is this the same buck? if so, score?

[KrazyKletus]

I think that both of these photos are the same buck. Give me your thoughts. Also, what do you think he would score? Thanks
http://www.michigan-sportsman.com/photopost/data/3041/medium/CDY_0115a.jpg
http://www.michigan-sportsman.com/photopost/data/3041/medium/CDY_0106a.jpg

[kingfishcam]

I think they are two different bucks. The first buck has some character to his rack, the second buck appears to have a much more uniform look.

[QDMAMAN]

Not the same buck. Look at the G4's on the left sides and also compare G2 and G3 lengths. definitely different bucks. Good problem to have.
First buck 115"
Second buck 125"

[Liv4Trappin]

For sure two different bucks there.The buck in the top pic has a broken tip on his left G-4.The buck in the bottom pic looks flawless.

Hard to tell the score for the bottom pic.Could use another angle,like a head on shot for inside spread,brow tines, and evenness.

The buck in the top pic might score around 120.
Now the buck in the bottom photo would most likely score higher than what Mr. QDMA has written.He appears to have very nice tine length even in his G-4's.Without an accurate inside spread measurement it does make it more difficult, but I would say the second buck is closer to 130-135.

Mike

[Domepiece]

for sure they are different . . . . first buck would score 120 maybe 125 but the second buck is a nice one . . . .we're talking high 130's maybe even 145
first one is a possible p&y but the second one is a no doubter

[Overdraw]

Same deer, and he's and old bastard.
Easy to imagine differences in the atlers at those angles, but they match. The real proof is in the body of the deer. Where he's putting on weight, ribs showing...

[Overdraw]

If look hard, you can see the extra mass on the G-3 left side. Same Monster.

[Domepiece]

just look at where the tines are positioned on the main beams . . . it's obvious if you do that

[Lyle7289]

Different Buck. The tines are longer and the characteris different

[GrizzlyBear]

Different bucks.

Same difference though, both shooters for sure.....

[chad helsel]

just different angles.
the left g3 is a dead give away as overdraw stated.